March 2026 | Excise Policy | EU Regulatory Framework
The proposed revision of the Tobacco Excise Directive represents a significant step in modernising the EU’s excise framework in light of evolving market realities and the emergence of new nicotine product categories. This paper approaches the revision from an implementation perspective: rather than evaluating the merits of the proposed changes, it examines the conditions under which harmonised minimum standards can function effectively across the European Union’s economically and administratively diverse Member State environments.
Drawing on Eurostat data, OECD regulatory benchmarks and the Commission’s own impact assessment, the analysis addresses three areas where legislative design choices carry material practical consequences: (i) the proportionality of common minimum rates relative to differences in income levels and price structures, (ii) the administrative feasibility of an expanded and periodically recalibrated excise framework covering novel nicotine products, and (iii) the dynamics of cross-border purchasing and illicit trade that interact with price differentials within the internal market.
The paper identifies a set of design and implementation considerations (relating to proportional calibration, administrative realism, legal clarity and evidence-based monitoring) that are relevant to ensuring the long-term credibility and effectiveness of the revised Directive.
Download the full paper.